TL;DR: Employers in California can refuse or delay your return to work after an injury if you lack medical clearance, your restrictions prevent safe job performance, or no reasonable accommodation is available. This most affects injured workers, who risk income loss. Refusals based on disability discrimination or retaliation are unlawful, so documentation and deadlines are critical.
Table of Contents
Yes, in some situations, an employer may refuse or delay your return to work after an injury. This usually happens when you are not medically cleared, when your work restrictions prevent you from performing essential job duties, or when no reasonable accommodation or modified work is available.
However, an employer cannot refuse your return based on disability discrimination or retaliation for filing a workers’ compensation claim. Whether a refusal is lawful depends on medical restrictions, job requirements, safety concerns, and how the employer applies California law to your situation.
In California, employers commonly point to reasons such as:
- You have not received medical clearance to return to work.
- Your restrictions prevent you from performing essential job duties safely.
- Reasonable accommodations or modified duties are not available.
- The position no longer exists for legitimate business reasons.
If your doctor clears you to return and you can work with reasonable accommodations, a refusal may raise legal concerns.
Understanding Return-To-Work Rights And Employer Duties After An Injury
Returning to work after a workplace injury is often more complicated than expected. Medical restrictions, safety issues, and job availability all affect whether and when you can return. Understanding your rights can help you recognize when an employer’s decision may cross legal boundaries.
When Employers Must Provide Reasonable Accommodations
Under the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), employers must provide reasonable accommodations to employees with disabilities, including those with temporary or permanent impairments caused by a work injury, unless doing so would create undue hardship.
Reasonable accommodations may include:
- Modified or reduced work hours.
- Physical changes to the workspace.
- Assistive devices or equipment.
- Temporary reassignment to available duties.
California law requires employers and employees to communicate and work together to identify reasonable accommodations before deciding whether and how an employee can come back to work.
Can Employers Refuse A Return Based On Safety Concerns?
Employers may delay or deny a return to work after a work injury if they can show that returning would pose a genuine safety risk to the employee or others. These decisions must be based on medical information and job-related facts, not assumptions or stereotypes.
Key points to remember:
- Safety concerns must relate directly to job duties and medical restrictions.
- Employers cannot use “safety” as a pretext for discrimination.
- Documentation supporting the decision may matter if the refusal is challenged.
Can My Employer Say My Job Is No Longer Available?
Job availability can affect return-to-work decisions, especially during restructuring, mergers, or financial difficulties. If a position is eliminated for legitimate business reasons, an employer may not be required to reinstate the employee.
If the position still exists, even in a modified form, the employer may need to:
- Return the employee to the same or an equivalent role under the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA).
- Consider reasonable accommodations or modified duties based on medical restrictions.
If the new role involves reduced pay, benefits, seniority, or significantly different duties, legal questions may arise. Employees may want clarification in writing and guidance on whether the changes comply with California and federal law.
What Benefits Can I Receive If I Cannot Return To Work?
California’s workers’ compensation system provides benefits to employees injured on the job, regardless of fault. These benefits may include:
- Medical treatment related to the injury.
- Temporary disability payments while you recover.
- Job retraining or assistance if you cannot return to your prior position.
In many cases, temporary disability benefits are limited to 104 weeks within a five-year period, with limited exceptions for certain serious conditions. When a doctor determines that your condition has stabilized, you may be considered to have reached Maximum Medical Improvement (MMI). At that point, the claim may shift to permanent disability benefits if a lasting impairment exists.
How Medical Evaluations Affect Return-To-Work Decisions
In California workers’ compensation cases, medical reports help determine whether you can return to work and under what restrictions. In some situations, the process may involve an additional medical evaluation, such as from a Qualified Medical Evaluator (QME) or Agreed Medical Evaluator (AME).
These evaluations can influence:
- Work restrictions
- Modified duty options
- Disability benefits
Providing accurate information about your symptoms and limitations is important throughout this process.
Can My Employer Refuse My Return Because I Filed Workers’ Compensation?
No. California law prohibits employers from retaliating against employees for filing a workers’ compensation claim or requesting reasonable accommodations. Retaliation may include:
- Termination
- Demotion
- Reduced hours
- Hostile treatment
If an employer refuses your return for reasons unrelated to your ability to work safely, the situation may involve unlawful retaliation or discrimination.
What To Do If Your Employer Refuses To Let You Return To Work After An Injury
If your employer denies your return, you do not have to accept the decision without explanation. Taking the steps below can help protect your rights.
- Ask for a Clear Explanation — Request a written explanation stating why your return was denied. This helps clarify whether the decision is based on medical restrictions, safety concerns, or business reasons.
- Obtain Medical Documentation — Most employers require written medical clearance before allowing a return to work. A healthcare provider may evaluate:
- Your injury and recovery
- Functional limitations
- Workplace risks
Employers generally should not ignore valid medical documentation without a legitimate reason.
- Request Reasonable Accommodations — You may ask for accommodations that allow you to work safely, such as lighter duties, reduced hours, or modified tasks. Employers must consider these requests in good faith, unless doing so would create undue hardship.
- Document Everything — Keep records of:
- Medical reports
- Employer communications
- Insurance correspondence
- Dates of meetings or phone calls
Documentation can be critical if disputes arise.
What The Return-To-Work Process Looks Like After A Workplace Injury
After a workplace injury, returning to work in California usually follows a clear process:
- Medical Work Status — A treating doctor determines whether you can return to work, return with restrictions, or remain off work.
- Review of Job Duties — The employer compares your medical restrictions to the essential duties of your position.
- Discussion of Modified Work — If restrictions apply, the employer and employee discuss possible accommodations or modified duties that allow a safe return.
- Employer Decision — The employer decides whether you can return to work and under what conditions, based on medical guidance, safety, and job availability.
- Dispute Resolution — If there is disagreement, additional medical review or legal guidance may be needed to clarify rights and next steps.
Common Questions About Return-To-Work Refusals
Delays in returning to work after an injury can be frustrating and confusing. You might have questions about what your employer can legally do or what you can do to protect yourself. Below, we’ve addressed common concerns that injured workers often raise.
Can I Sue My Employer For A Workplace Injury In California?
Generally, workers’ compensation is the exclusive remedy for workplace injuries in California, meaning you usually cannot sue your employer. Limited exceptions may apply, such as intentional harm, lack of insurance, or certain third-party situations.
If you’re thinking, “I need a personal injury lawyer,” chances are, you do. They can help determine whether an exception applies, whether a separate third-party claim is available, and whether your employer’s actions raise issues such as retaliation or discrimination. Because these situations depend on specific facts and deadlines, legal guidance can help clarify your options before important rights are lost.
What If I Believe The Refusal Was Unlawful?
Employees who believe their employer ignored or disrespected their rights should consider speaking with an employment attorney. They may also file a complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) or, in California, with the California Civil Rights Department (CRD). Keeping records of all messages and documents related to the issue is essential.
Sometimes, the lawyer may suggest talking to the employer first to try to fix the problem. The attorney can assist in negotiations on the employee’s behalf. They can also evaluate whether the employer had any lawful grounds for denying the return to work.
What If A Third Party Caused My Injury?
If someone other than your employer caused your work injury, such as a driver in a car accident or a contractor on a job site, you may be able to file a third-party claim. In California, there are two different deadlines, or “statutes of limitations,” depending on the type of claim:
- Third-Party Injury Claim — You generally have two years from the date of the accident or injury to file a claim against a third party. In cases involving the delayed discovery of injury or harm, different timelines may apply.
- Workers’ Compensation — You typically have one year from the date of injury to file a workers’ compensation claim. However, this deadline can be extended in cases involving cumulative trauma or delayed discovery.
It is essential to know that these are separate claims with different time limits.
Know Your Rights After A Work Injury With Help From Our Lawyers
Returning to work after a workplace injury should be based on your health, doctor’s recommendations, and legal rights. It should not depend on your employer’s convenience or assumptions about your abilities. California law protects injured workers. However, these rights only help you if you know about them and take action to enforce them.
If your employer has refused to let you return to work after your doctor cleared you, or if you suspect discrimination or retaliation, don’t face this challenge alone. Every situation is unique, and the specific facts of your case will determine your best legal options.
At the AK Law Firm, our workplace injury lawyers help injured workers understand return-to-work issues, medical restrictions, and employer obligations under California law. Reviewing your situation with legal guidance can help you determine your next steps and protect your rights.
Call us at (888) 488-1391 to schedule an appointment. Alternatively, you can complete our “Do I Have A Case?” form.
