My Dashcam Is Not Working After a Crash. What Can an Injury Lawyer Help Preserve?

TL;DR: An injury lawyer can help preserve your dashcam, storage, existing files, cloud copies, and records of the device’s condition and handling. Other potential evidence includes witness accounts, photographs, and vehicle records. Counsel can assess the availability of qualified technical assistance, but a malfunction does not establish whether footage exists or whether anyone can recover it.

An injury lawyer can help preserve your malfunctioning dashcam, its storage, existing recordings, and records explaining the equipment’s condition and handling. The available evidence may also include phone downloads, cloud copies, shared clips, and recordings from other sources.

A dashcam that no longer works leaves several questions unanswered. Its condition does not establish when it failed, whether it recorded the collision, or whether another device holds a copy.

The original equipment and related records may remain useful even when you cannot access a recording. Counsel can assess qualified technical help and other crash evidence before anyone repairs, resets, replaces, or discards the device.

Table of Contents
    REVIEWED BY
    Arash Khorsandi, Esq., Attorney at Law
    Arash Khorsandi

    California State Bar #249405
    Admitted 2007
    California Personal Injury Attorney

    Last reviewed:

    My Dashcam Is Not Working. What Should I Preserve Before Replacing It or Attempting Recovery?

    Preserve the original camera, its storage, existing copies, and details about the malfunction before troubleshooting, resetting, repairing, or replacing the equipment. Record when the device last worked, when you first noticed the problem, and what happened afterward.

    Some dashcams automatically replace older recordings as storage fills. Continued use could overwrite files that remain on the device. Avoid further recording or testing until you obtain device-specific guidance. If the camera remains active, ask a qualified professional how to safely preserve its current state.

    The useful material extends beyond a crash video. Photographs of visible damage, error messages, service receipts, and prior downloads may help explain the equipment’s condition and available evidence.

    Key Facts About What an Injury Lawyer Can Help Preserve

    • The dashcam and its storage may contain evidence. Keep the original camera, memory card, and related equipment. Avoid resetting, repairing, or testing them before obtaining guidance.
    • Continued use could overwrite existing recordings. A lawyer can help assess preservation options before additional recording changes the available files.
    • Existing copies may survive a camera malfunction. Preserve known phone downloads, computer files, cloud recordings, and shared clips. Do not assume the camera recorded the crash or uploaded footage.
    • Device condition and handling records help document the evidence. Keep photographs, error messages, repair records, and notes showing who accessed or handled the equipment and when.
    • Qualified technical help may be appropriate. A lawyer can assess whether a digital-evidence examiner should inspect the device before repairs or recovery attempts. Recovery is not guaranteed.
    • Other evidence can support an injury claim without dashcam footage. Witness statements, scene photographs, collision reports, and vehicle records may help establish what happened.

    What to Record About Your Device and Its Files

    Use this checklist to keep track of the device, its files, and anyone who has handled them. If you don’t know an answer, leave it blank. Do not turn on, open, test, or repair the device just to complete the checklist.

    What to Check Information to Record
    Known Model and Storage Brand, model, visible serial number, and known memory card or internal storage.
    Current Condition Visible damage, displayed messages, apparent power state, and when you first noticed the problem.
    File Copies Existing videos or files saved on a phone, computer, cloud account, or shared with others.
    Last Access When someone last viewed, downloaded, connected, tested, or attempted to repair the device or files.
    People Who Handled It Who had the device or files, what they did with them, when they handled them, and where the items are now.
    Question for Your Lawyer Should the device or files be examined or preserved before any repair, replacement, return, or disposal?

    Keep the original device and existing files. Replacing the equipment does not preserve its condition or the files it may contain. Ask your lawyer before arranging repairs, returning the device under warranty, or disposing of it.

    The Dashcam and Its Storage

    Your camera and its storage are distinct items that a lawyer can help preserve for possible examination. Depending on the model, the system may use removable storage, internal storage, or connected equipment.

    Preserve the camera with its existing components and accessories, including any known memory card, power cable, or mounting equipment. Keep identifying records, such as the manual and purchase receipt, to help establish the device’s model and features.

    If the camera remains inside a towed or totaled vehicle, tell counsel where the vehicle is stored. Keep any tow-yard notices and release deadlines. Ask about preserving the camera and storage before the vehicle is transferred, repaired, sold, or disposed of.

    What the Malfunction Does and Does Not Establish

    The reported malfunction establishes what you observed, rather than whether the crash recording exists. A blank screen, a missing clip, and an app connection issue are distinct observations.

    A lawyer can review the reported problem and determine whether a qualified digital-evidence examiner should assess the equipment. That examiner may identify suitable collection methods and explain the risks of altering stored information.

    Do not open the camera or remove storage solely to investigate the malfunction. Keep a record of what you observed so counsel can compare your account with any later technical findings.

    Personal injury evidence review showing a man examining dashcam footage on multiple computer screens

    What If the Dashcam Works but the Crash Footage Is Missing?

    A working camera does not establish that it recorded or saved the collision. The recording may be missing, stored elsewhere, or inaccessible through the available app or device.

    Preserve any existing file listings, error messages, account notices, and information about when someone last accessed the footage. Do not reset the camera or run recovery software to search for missing files. Ask counsel whether the missing recording warrants further technical examination.

    Existing Recordings and Separately Saved Copies

    Existing recordings may survive outside the malfunctioning camera, including downloads, exports, messages, backups, and files stored in the account. These are separate preservation targets because replacing the camera does not necessarily protect or erase them.

    A useful inventory identifies the location and source of each known copy. Distinguish a file you actually saved from an assumption that an app or service uploaded everything.

    Original Files and Longer Recordings

    A short crash clip may omit details needed to understand how the collision occurred. Longer recordings may show:

    • The approach to the collision and surrounding traffic.
    • Vehicle movements before impact.
    • Additional camera views or audio.
    • Events immediately after the crash.

    Original files may also contain information not visible during ordinary playback, such as recording timestamps or other file details. Edited or converted copies may not preserve all of that information.

    Keep information about any known clock error so counsel can assess the recording’s timeline. A qualified examiner may also need the original recording format and compatible playback software.

    Phone Downloads and Cloud Copies

    An app or cloud subscription does not guarantee that the dashcam uploaded footage of the crash. Existing upload confirmations, account notices, or download records may help establish whether a copy was saved.

    For cloud-held recordings, pay attention to:

    • Upload Status: Whether existing records confirm that a particular video was successfully saved.
    • Storage Limits: Whether the service has automatic deletion rules or limited storage.
    • Retention Deadlines: When available recordings may expire or become inaccessible.
    • Account Changes: Whether canceling a subscription, closing an account, or changing connected equipment could affect access.

    Tell your lawyer about any known deadlines or planned account changes before taking action. Counsel can assess whether additional steps are needed to preserve available recordings.

    Discuss the Evidence You Already Have

    Call Arash Law at (888) 488-1391 for a free case evaluation. Have your device details, known copies, and repair history available to discuss potential preservation needs related to your injury claim.

    Records of the Device’s Condition and Handling

    Records showing what happened to your dashcam after the crash may help a lawyer understand whether the equipment or its files were changed. These records can also help distinguish what you personally observed from what a technician or another person reported.

    The two main areas to document are previous repair attempts and who handled the evidence.

    Repair Records and Previous Recovery Attempts

    If someone already tried to repair the camera or recover footage, keep records of that work. They may help a lawyer or qualified examiner understand what was done and whether the equipment or files were affected.

    Useful records include:

    • Repair Findings: What the technician reported about the camera or storage.
    • Software Used: Names of programs used to examine or recover files.
    • Work Dates: When repairs, resets, formatting, or recovery attempts occurred.
    • Communication Records: Repair receipts, service reports, and messages with technicians.
    • Recovered Files: Any recordings or other files produced during the work.

    Tell your lawyer about any attempts you made yourself, even if they did not work. Previous attempts do not necessarily mean all footage was lost.

    Possession and Transfer Records

    Knowing who handled the equipment can help explain changes to its condition or stored files. This information may also help establish the history of evidence used in an injury claim.

    Keep available records showing:

    • Who Had the Equipment: The person, repair shop, insurer, or other party that possessed the camera or storage.
    • When It Changed Hands: Dates of transfers, deliveries, or returns.
    • What Happened During Each Transfer: Any reported inspection, copying, repair, or testing.
    • Proof of Transfer: Shipping receipts, repair intake forms, or written delivery acknowledgments.

    File histories should also identify who supplied each copy and how you received it. Digital evidence preservation guidance emphasizes documenting sources and transfers to support file integrity.

    Other Crash Evidence When No Dashcam Recording Exists

    Other evidence may help establish the collision’s circumstances and resulting losses even when your dashcam provides no usable footage. California car accident lawyers can assess those sources alongside any available device evidence.

    Potential material includes:

    • Witness Accounts: Contact information and descriptions of what people observed.
    • Scene Photographs: Vehicle positions, traffic controls, road conditions, and visible damage.
    • Vehicle Evidence: Inspection photographs, repair records, and available vehicle data.
    • Official Records: Collision reports, dispatch records, and relevant responder observations.
    • Injury and Loss Records: Treatment records, medical bills, work restrictions, and income information.

    Each source answers different questions, so the missing video does not make the other records less useful. A malfunction does not, by itself, establish that a product defect caused the crash.

    Recordings Held by Other People

    Other cameras near the collision scene may have recorded relevant events. Potential sources include:

    • Other Drivers: Dashcams in nearby vehicles.
    • Businesses: Security cameras facing roads, parking lots, or entrances.
    • Property Owners: Surveillance systems that may have captured the collision.
    • Public Agencies: Traffic cameras or other recording systems operated by government entities.

    If you know of a nearby camera, note its location, the approximate time of the crash, and who may control the recording. This information can help counsel assess requests for traffic camera footage of a car accident.

    A nearby camera does not necessarily mean footage exists or remains available. A lawyer can assess preservation requests and possible legal steps, but sending a preservation letter does not guarantee that the owner will keep or disclose a recording.

    Frequently Asked Questions About Evidence From a Malfunctioning Dashcam

    Personal injury attorney discusses dashcam evidence preservation with an injured client

    Can a Lawyer Help Preserve Evidence Before Confirming That Footage Exists?

    Yes, a lawyer can help preserve the equipment and related records before anyone confirms that a recording exists. The device, existing copies, and handling history each provide a separate starting point. An examination may clarify what remains available, but recovery is uncertain. Ask what preservation work the firm would undertake if it accepts representation.

    Does Buying a Replacement Camera Mean I Can Discard the Original?

    No. Keep the original camera and storage available for legal review. Ask your lawyer whether technical evidence collection is needed before anyone repairs, returns, exchanges, or discards the equipment.

    Should I Keep Files That Appear Unhelpful to My Claim?

    Yes, preserve relevant files even if you think they hurt your claim. Give counsel the complete material and explain your concerns without deleting or changing anything. Evidence Code § 413 addresses willful suppression of evidence. CACI No. 204 addresses intentional concealment or destruction of evidence.

    What If an Insurer Requests the Original Camera or Memory Card?

    Keep the insurer’s request and ask counsel to review it before transferring the original camera or memory card. Note the response deadline and whether the insurer requests inspection, copying, testing, or possession.

    Your own insurer may have contractual rights to information and cooperation under your policy. Another driver’s insurer does not automatically have those same contractual rights. Counsel can review the request, applicable obligations, and appropriate steps to preserve the evidence during any inspection or transfer.

    Discuss Your Available Evidence With Arash Law

    You can request an injury case evaluation without first recovering footage or confirming that the camera recorded the crash. Have your equipment inventory, existing copies, handling records, and insurance requests available.

    Call Arash Law at (888) 488-1391 for a free case evaluation. The team can discuss your injury claim and potential preservation needs without promising footage recovery.


    Sources

    • California Evidence Code § 413: Addresses willful suppression of evidence.
      https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=EVID&sectionNum=413.
    • California Code of Civil Procedure § 2031.010: Addresses inspection, copying, testing, and production of documents, electronically stored information, and tangible evidence during civil discovery.
      https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?sectionNum=2031.010.&lawCode=CCP
    • National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST): Digital evidence preservation, storage, and handling practices.
      https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/ir/2022/NIST.IR.8387.pdf
    • Scientific Working Group on Digital Evidence (SWGDE): Best Practices for Digital Evidence Collection, Version 2.0, November 20, 2025. Guidance on equipment collection, documentation, and chain of custody.
      https://swgde.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/2025-11-20-Best-Practices-for-Digital-Evidence-Collection-18-F-002-2.0.pdf
    • Scientific Working Group on Digital Evidence (SWGDE): Best Practices for Digital Evidence Acquisition, Preservation, and Analysis from Cloud Service Providers, Version 1.1, January 13, 2025. Guidance on preserving and collecting cloud evidence.
      https://www.swgde.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/SWGDE-23-F-004-1.1-Best-Practices-for-Digital-Evidence-Acquisition-Preservation-and-Analysis-from-Cloud-Service-Providers.pdf
    • Judicial Council of California: Civil Jury Instructions (CACI), 2026 Edition and July 2026 Supplement. CACI No. 204 addresses willful suppression of evidence.
      https://courts.ca.gov/partners/california-jury-instructions/civil-jury-instructions-resource-center/civil-jury-instructions
    • State Bar of California: Arash Khorsandi’s attorney license record and admission date.
      https://apps.calbar.ca.gov/attorney/Licensee/Detail/249405
    • VIOFO: A119M Pro Dash Camera User Manual. Explains loop recording and automatic overwriting of older files when storage becomes insufficient. https://viofotech.com/download/manual/A119MPRO/A119MProEnglishManual.pdf
    • Scientific Working Group on Digital Evidence (SWGDE): Best Practices for Data Acquisition from Digital Video Recorders, Version 1.4. Guidance on digital-video acquisition and preservation. https://www.swgde.org/documents/published-complete-listing/17-v-002-1-4/

    Disclaimer

    This article provides educational information and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Consult a licensed California attorney about your circumstances.

    Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Arash Law — (888) 488-1391.

    Last Updated on:
    ABOUT THE AUTHOR
    Arash Khorsandi, ESQ
    Founder, Arash Law

    Arash Khorsandi, Esq., is the owner and founder of Arash Law, an established personal injury law firm in California. Over the years, Arash has built a team of experienced lawyers, former insurance company adjusters, and skilled paralegal staff who work to pursue positive outcomes for his clients’ cases. Our California personal injury law firm handles claims across multiple practice areas.

    Recover Lost Wages, Property Damage, and Medical Bills.
    Arash Law Practice Area Border/Divider

    We’ll review what happened and tell you what options may be available.

    MAKE THEM PAY, CALL AK!
    24-hour accident hotline: (888) 488-1391

    DISCLAIMER: Information provided on this blog is not formal legal advice. It is generic legal information. Under no circumstances should the information on this page be relied upon when deciding the proper course of a legal action. Always obtain a free and confidential case evaluation from a reputable attorney near you if you think you might have a personal injury lawsuit.

    Check More From Our Award-Winning Law Firm

    Thank You, We’ll contact you shortly.

    Schedule Your Consultation with Arash
    or call him directly at (213) 805-7789
    Arash Khorsandi