TL;DR: You can seek legal advice about your injuries immediately after the other driver’s arrest. An arrest does not establish fault, and criminal charges or a conviction may never follow. California civil injury cases also have separate filing deadlines that do not automatically pause for criminal proceedings. A lawyer can review your injuries, insurance contacts, available records, and filing dates without waiting for a criminal outcome.
No, you do not need to wait for the other driver’s criminal case to be resolved before consulting a personal injury lawyer. California law treats criminal proceedings and civil injury claims as separate legal matters. That means you can explore your insurance and civil injury options even when you do not know why police made the arrest.
A criminal case may involve charges, prosecution, or a conviction. However, an arrest does not necessarily lead to these outcomes, nor does it establish that the other driver caused the accident. In contrast, a civil injury case focuses on determining liability and pursuing compensation for losses such as medical expenses and lost wages.
Those differences matter because civil cases follow legal filing deadlines that don’t pause just because a criminal case is underway. A personal injury lawyer can review those concerns, identify applicable deadlines, and help you determine which records to preserve. Consulting them can give you more time to preserve evidence, build a well-supported case, and file it within the necessary window.
Key Facts About Criminal and Civil Cases After a California Traffic Accident
- An arrest does not establish criminal guilt. Prosecutors decide whether to pursue criminal charges. A criminal defendant is presumed innocent unless the government proves guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
- A civil claim does not require a criminal conviction. A civil case can proceed even if the criminal charges are dropped, the driver is acquitted, or the criminal case is still pending.
- Civil claims use a lower standard of proof. Ordinary civil claims use the more-likely-than-not standard (California Civil Jury Instructions (CACI) No. 200), rather than proof beyond a reasonable doubt, which is required in criminal charges.
- Civil injury claims have separate filing deadlines. CCP § 335.1 generally provides two years from the date of your injury, not the other driver’s arrest, to file a personal injury lawsuit. A pending criminal matter does not automatically suspend that deadline. Shorter deadlines apply to claims involving a public entity.
- An attorney can review evidence before criminal proceedings conclude. Lawyers can request documents and review available accident records, medical documentation, and insurer communications before the other driver’s criminal case resolves.
Table of Contents
The Other Driver Was Arrested After the Accident, and I Don’t Know What Will Happen. Should I Wait for the Authorities Before Seeking Legal Advice About My Injuries?
You can consult a California personal injury lawyer before learning why the other driver was arrested or whether prosecutors will file charges. You do not need a criminal conviction to explore an insurance claim or civil lawsuit.
An attorney can begin reviewing your situation using the information you already have. For example, they can:
- Review the accident date, your injuries, and available medical records.
- Examine insurance communications, coverage questions, and any settlement offers.
- Identify applicable civil filing deadlines and possible exceptions.
- Determine which accident records and other evidence may need preservation.
- Review the official notices and identify any remaining questions about the arrest.
A lawyer can already assess these issues while authorities independently decide whether the arrest warrants further criminal action.
Can Waiting for the Other Driver’s Criminal Case Affect Your Injury Claim?
Yes. Waiting for the criminal case to conclude could cause you to miss civil filing deadlines or lose useful evidence.
California generally gives injured people two years to file a personal injury lawsuit against a private party under Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) § 335.1. For injury claims against public entities, Government Code § 911.2 generally requires that a claim be presented within six months. A separate lawsuit deadline follows the government claim process.
A pending criminal case does not automatically pause these deadlines.
Beyond deadlines, evidence of your accident can disappear quickly. Video from the other driver’s dashcam, your dashcam, or a nearby business or traffic camera can be overwritten within days. Memories fade, witnesses move, and vehicles may be repaired or disposed of. If an insurer has taken your vehicle, counsel can assess options for preserving evidence while the insurer holds the car.
A personal injury lawyer can review the deadlines that may apply to your civil claim and help you build a well-supported claim without waiting for a criminal outcome.
What Does the Other Driver’s Arrest Mean for Your Injury Claim?
The other driver’s arrest is a law enforcement action, not a court ruling. That means it may provide information relevant to your injury claim. However, it does not establish the driver’s civil liability.
The reason for the arrest, the existence of charges, and the outcome of any prosecution remain separate questions. That means even if a court later convicts the driver, that conviction does not automatically guarantee a successful civil claim.
Can You Pursue a Civil Injury Claim Without Criminal Charges?
Yes. Your claim depends on evidence of civil responsibility, not the existence of a criminal prosecution.
In the criminal system, a prosecutor decides whether to file charges, and the state must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. In contrast, a negligence claim generally needs evidence showing that:
- The driver owed you a duty to act with reasonable care to avoid causing harm to others (Civil Code § 1714).
- The driver failed to meet that duty.
- The driver’s conduct caused your injuries.
- You suffered legally recognized damages.
In essence, you must show that the other driver more likely than not caused your harm. That standard, preponderance of the evidence, is a lower bar than the criminal standard. That is why a civil case can move forward even if charges are never filed.
An attorney may examine witness statements, photographs, vehicle damage, available video, medical records, and insurance information to establish these key elements of negligence.
Can a Criminal Outcome Affect Your Civil Case?
A criminal proceeding may produce testimony, records, or findings relevant to civil litigation. Their effect on your case depends on the specific circumstances of the accident and the applicable evidence rules.
However, a conviction does not automatically establish every element of your claim or determine the compensation you may recover.
Likewise, dismissed charges or an acquittal do not necessarily prevent a civil claim.
Can You Start an Insurance Claim While the Arrest Is Under Investigation?
You can start an insurance claim without waiting for authorities to announce criminal charges.
Your first step is to report the accident to the appropriate insurance company and provide the information you already have. This may include the crash date, location, vehicle details, medical records, and available evidence. You can also mention the arrest without guessing why it happened.
Depending on the circumstances, you may seek compensation through:
- The Other Driver’s Liability Insurance: This coverage may cover your injuries and related losses if the other driver is legally responsible and the policy applies.
- Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist (UM/UIM) Coverage: Your own policy may provide benefits if the responsible driver has no insurance or insufficient coverage.
- Medical Payments (MedPay) Coverage: If included in your policy, MedPay may help cover qualifying medical expenses regardless of who caused the accident.
An attorney can review these coverage options, help you identify the appropriate insurer, and assess any information or documents the insurer requests.
What If an Insurance Adjuster Contacts You Before the Arrest Is Explained?
You can ask the insurance adjuster to identify the claim, explain the information requested, and provide relevant communications in writing. You do not need to guess why the arrest occurred.
Before signing a release, accepting a final settlement, or providing a detailed recorded statement, consider seeking legal advice about your rights and obligations.
A civil attorney can assess how the requested information, available medical evidence, and proposed settlement may affect your claim.
Should You Contact the Authorities Before Consulting a Lawyer?
You do not need to contact the authorities again before consulting a personal injury lawyer. You can seek legal advice based on the information already available to you.
If you want to clarify the status of the other driver’s arrest, you may contact the investigating agency. If prosecutors later file charges, the appropriate prosecutor’s office or victim-services contact may provide information about available notices and procedures.
Your civil attorney can help identify which information may matter to your injury claim. However, the attorney does not control the police investigation or prosecution.
What Information Should You Give a Personal Injury Lawyer After the Arrest?
You should provide the information you already have and identify anything that remains unknown. You do not need to obtain a complete criminal or civil case file before arranging a consultation.
During your consultation, an injury attorney may ask about specific dates, notices, records, and communications, so prioritize giving them the following information and related evidence:
- Accident Details: The crash date, location, vehicles involved, and any available photos and videos of the scene.
- Arrest Information: The law enforcement agency that made the arrest, any known case number, and what authorities actually told you about the arrest.
- Official Notices: Letters, emails, court notices, or other communications you received from law enforcement or prosecutors.
- Insurance Contacts: Insurer names, claim numbers, adjuster messages, and any settlement offers.
- Medical Information: Treatment dates, diagnoses, medical bills, and any scheduled appointments.
- Financial Losses: Proof of missed work, transportation expenses, and other accident-related costs.
- Previous Communications: Recorded statements you provided, documents you signed, or payments you received.
An attorney can review these materials, identify missing information, and decide whether additional records are necessary to support your civil claim.
Information to Track After the Other Driver’s Arrest
You can manage arrest-related information and your civil injury concerns in a single organizer without treating them as a single case. Keep verified facts separate from unanswered questions.
| What to Track | Information to Record | Questions for Review |
|---|---|---|
| Known Information About the Criminal Case |
|
Why did the arrest occur?
Have prosecutors filed charges? Are proceedings scheduled? |
| Insurance Information |
|
What coverage applies?
Which requests remain outstanding? |
| Important Dates for Your Civil Claim |
|
Which filing deadlines apply?
Does any notice require prompt attention? |
| Possible Financial Assistance and Payments |
|
Could restitution or victim assistance apply?
Would payments cover overlapping losses? |
Note: List unknown information as “Unknown” or “Not yet confirmed.” Do not record an anticipated payment as money already received. Track each payment’s source and the expenses it covers to help identify overlapping recoveries.
This organizer can help you show an attorney which questions need attention and which dates may affect your claim. Update it when you receive new notices, records, or insurance communications.
How Should You Track Payments From Different Sources?
You should keep a separate record of each payment, its source, the loss it covers, and the date you received it. This can help your attorney identify potential reimbursement obligations or overlapping recoveries.
For example, you might receive an insurance payment for medical expenses and later become eligible for criminal restitution, which is money a court orders a convicted person to pay for losses caused by the crime.
Penal Code § 1202.4(j) requires crediting restitution collected against other judgments for the same losses against the defendant. Other reimbursement and offset rules may also apply.
Do not add every possible payment together as though each represents a separate recovery for the same expense. An attorney can assess how the payment sources interact.
Consult Arash Law While the Arrest Details Remain Unclear
Arash Law can review your injuries and available accident information without waiting for a criminal decision.
Our California car accident lawyers can assess possible civil claims, insurance communications, and filing dates. You can also discuss what information you have received from authorities and what remains unknown.
Call (888) 488-1391 for a free case evaluation. Hablamos español.
Could Criminal Restitution or Victim Assistance Help With Your Expenses?
Criminal restitution (a court-ordered monetary payment) or victim assistance may provide financial relief in qualifying circumstances, but an arrest does not guarantee either. Your eligibility depends on the underlying facts and the applicable program or criminal proceedings.
When Could Criminal Restitution Become Relevant?
Criminal restitution may become relevant if prosecutors pursue a case that results in a qualifying conviction. Under Penal Code § 1202.4, courts generally must order restitution for qualifying economic losses caused by the defendant’s criminal conduct.
These losses may include medical expenses and lost wages. However, a restitution order does not guarantee that the defendant will pay promptly or in full.
You can ask the appropriate prosecutor’s victim-services office whether restitution procedures will apply if criminal charges are eventually filed.
Keep copies of medical bills, wage records, and payment receipts. Your civil attorney can help you identify any overlaps between restitution and a potential recovery from your civil claim.
Can You Apply for Victim Assistance Before a Criminal Conviction?
Yes. The California Victim Compensation Board (CalVCB) does not require a criminal conviction to qualify for assistance. However, applicants must satisfy the program’s crime-related eligibility requirements and other conditions.
CalVCB may help eligible victims with certain expenses, including medical treatment and mental health services. Qualifying crimes include driving under the influence, hit-and-run, and vehicular manslaughter; an ordinary traffic accident does not automatically qualify.
If the arrest’s reason remains unknown, ask CalVCB whether the known circumstances support an application. Do not assume that the arrest alone establishes eligibility.
Frequently Asked Questions About Seeking Legal Advice After the Other Driver’s Arrest
Do I Need the Arrest Report Before Speaking With a Personal Injury Attorney?
No. You can consult an attorney without an arrest report. Provide any accident details, official notices, photographs, and other records already available to you.
Your attorney can assess whether an arrest report, collision report, or other investigative records may be relevant and legally obtainable.
What Should I Do If I Missed Work Due to My Injuries While the Criminal Case Is Pending?
Document your lost income and explore your compensation options without waiting for the criminal case to conclude. Keep pay stubs, work schedules, employer letters, and medical records showing how your injuries affected your ability to work.
A personal injury lawyer can review these records and assess whether you can seek compensation for lost wages and other related losses.
What If I Am a Minor in This Situation?
You can still pursue a personal injury claim if you are under 18. However, a parent, legal guardian, or court-appointed guardian typically must act on your behalf in a civil lawsuit.
State law will generally pause the filing deadline for personal injury lawsuits until you turn 18 (CCP § 352). However, different rules apply to claims against public entities.
You and your parent or guardian can consult a personal injury lawyer without waiting for authorities to resolve the other driver’s arrest.
Can I Receive Restitution and a Civil Settlement for the Same Accident?
Yes. You may pursue criminal restitution and civil compensation when legally available, but payments for overlapping losses must be properly accounted for. That’s because you generally cannot collect twice from the same person for the same loss.
For example, under Penal Code § 1202.4(j), if the driver already paid your medical bills through restitution, that payment may be credited against a civil judgment covering those same bills. Additional reimbursement rules may apply depending on the payments involved.
Will I Have to Testify in a Criminal Trial to Win My Personal Injury Case?
No. Winning a civil injury case does not require testifying in a criminal trial. Your civil claim depends on evidence of negligence and resulting losses.
However, if prosecutors file charges and you receive a subpoena to testify, you generally must comply. Testifying in that proceeding is separate from pursuing compensation for your injuries.
Can a Personal Injury Lawyer Represent Me in the Other Driver’s Criminal Case?
Yes. A California personal injury lawyer may also represent you as a crime victim in certain criminal proceedings if they are qualified to do so and agree to take on that role.
However, they do not automatically represent you, and they cannot take over the prosecution, which the district attorney usually handles.
Talk to Arash Law About Your Injury Claim After the Other Driver’s Arrest
You can request a free case evaluation even when the reason for the other driver’s arrest remains unclear. Bring available medical records, insurance communications, and official notices, even if you do not have a complete file. Arash Law can review those materials and identify deadlines or next steps that may require attention.
The consultation focuses on your civil injury rights. It does not mean the firm controls the prosecution or provides criminal defense. Arash Law handles personal injury cases on a contingency fee basis. That means you pay no attorney fees unless we recover compensation for you. Case costs may apply under the written fee agreement.
Call (888) 488-1391, available 24/7, to request a free case evaluation. Hablamos español.
Sources
- California Legislature. Code of Civil Procedure § 335.1 — General personal injury filing deadline. California Legislative Information. https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?sectionNum=335.1&lawCode=CCP
- California Legislature. Code of Civil Procedure § 352 — Tolling of certain civil filing deadlines during minority. California Legislative Information. https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?sectionNum=352.&lawCode=CCP
- California Legislature. Government Code § 911.2 — Government claim presentation deadlines. California Legislative Information. https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?sectionNum=911.2&lawCode=GOV
- California Legislature. Insurance Code § 11580.2 — Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage and claim preservation. California Legislative Information. https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?sectionNum=11580.2&lawCode=INS
- California Legislature. Penal Code § 1202.4 — Criminal restitution, eligible losses, and crediting payments. California Legislative Information. https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?sectionNum=1202.4&lawCode=PEN
- Judicial Council of California. Judicial Council of California Civil Jury Instructions, CACI No. 200 — Obligation to Prove: More Likely True Than Not True. https://courts.ca.gov/system/files/file/judicial_council_of_california_civil_jury_instructions_2026.pdf
- California Courts. Guide to Criminal Court in California — Criminal charges, prosecution, criminal court procedures, and defendants’ rights.
https://selfhelp.courts.ca.gov/criminal-court- California Victim Compensation Board. Who Is Eligible and Restitution — Victim assistance eligibility, qualifying crimes, and restitution procedures. https://victims.ca.gov/for-victims/who-is-eligible/
https://victims.ca.gov/restitution/Disclaimer
The information on this page is for general educational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is formed by reading or relying on this content. If you were injured, consult a licensed California personal injury attorney about your specific situation. Arash Law — (888) 488-1391.

